I give them a 3. But I will not be buying them again. I am a true size 13. Purchased the blk boots last year, and squeezed into them all season. Very uncomfortable. Then, hoping that they corrected the sz issue I purchased another sz 13. Still to small, I couldn’t believe it. Disappointing, because the boot is a solid boot. Water proof/rugged exterior. Just too darn small and uncomfortable. I gave them to my brother after reaching out to the Kujo team and they offering no reconciliation. Just asked me if they were worn. I said yes, never a response back.